Oliver put an offer on a home when his wife Melissa was away on business. Since moving in, the two homeowners are confronted almost daily by their home's dysfunctions. Now with a six month-old, an active social life and two busy careers, Melissa craves a headache free-home that they can BOTH choose, while Oliver is committed to making their starter home last for the rest of their lives. David must find a better-functioning house within their neighborhood, while Hilary is tasked with making the most of an unfinished basement.